Jump to content

Why so much of our wisdom about the 3 Wise Men of the Christmas story is actually incorrect


Recommended Posts

  • Moderator

Why so much of our wisdom about the 3 Wise Men of the Christmas story is actually incorrect

FOX NEWS    OPINION              Published December 16, 2022 4:00am EST

You may know the song, 'We Three Kings of Orient Are,' but do you know the truth about the mysterious magi described in the Christmas story?


PROGRAMMING NOTE: Stream the newly released special "The Wise Men Who Found Christmas" on Fox Nation.

They are among the most beloved characters of Christmas; appearing annually at school pageants, celebrated on the feast of the Epiphany, and in carols sung throughout the season. But how much do we really know about those mysterious wise men who sought the Christ Child? It turns out very little—and much of what we think we know is incorrect. 

Despite the famous song, "We Three Kings of Orient Are," there were very likely more than three of them (the Gospel mentions three gifts, not three men), they were not kings, and they did not hail from the Far East. 

Historical, biblical and archeological evidence paints a very different picture of the Gospel’s "Wise Men from the East." Using these neglected early sources I created a picture book adventure titled, "The Wise Men Who Found Christmas." But in the course of a narrative, I could only hint at what I discovered.   

First off, who were the "Wise Men"? Magi were mystical characters, trained to see the unseen. They were star-gazers, mathematicians, theologians, interpreters of dreams, and quite possibly part of a priestly caste with Zoroastrian or even Jewish roots. And like other wise men at the time, they would have served a king. But which one?  

We know that the Magi did not come from the Far East or even Persia. Saints and scribes in the first and second century—including Tertullian, Eusebius, and Clement of Rome all attest that the Magi came from "East of Judea." Justin Martyr writing less than 100 years after Jesus’ resurrection is even more explicit: "The Magi came from Arabia and worshipped Him…"   

There are a couple of good reasons to suspect that they came from what was then the capital of Arabia, the Kingdom of Nabatea—modern-day Petra. Raymond Brown, the biblical scholar tells us "the Jewish Community in Northern Arabia was one of the largest ancient Jewish communities in the history of the Jewish people." So the Jewish prophecies of a coming Messiah would have been well known to the inhabitants of Nabatea.   

Father Dwight Longenecker, who has researched the historic Wise Men for years suggests that the gifts the Magi carried also point to the Kingdom of Nabatea as their home. Frankincense and myrrh were produced there from the tree sap extracted solely from Arabian trees. And Nabatea controlled the Mines of Midean, also known as the legendary King Solomon’s mines.   

What was the nature of the Wise Men’s journey? Matthew’s Gospel in a mere twelve lines describes what was very likely a royal diplomatic mission to the dangerous Herod, mingled with a personal spiritual quest. 

Old Testament scholar and Cambridge-educated linguist, Margaret Barker offers a truly tantalizing possibility. Barker believes that the Wise Men may have been descendants of the First Temple royal Jewish priesthood—the Order of Melkhizedek- expelled from the Temple 700 years before Christ.  

Far from the Magi "gift drop" that has become a cultural fixture, the items they carried suggest a far more serious religious mission. Barker points to Philo of Alexandria, who reports that gold was used in the vestments of the Royal priests of the first temple.  

Frankincense was burned in the first temple and myrrh oil was kept in the holy of holies. Why? It was used to anoint kings and members of the royal high priesthood. 

Shattering the later day accounts of the emperors bearing gifts to a messiah, it makes far more sense that a group of exiled Jewish high priests came, not only to worship this Messiah, but to anoint him into their priesthood and restore the first temple.

There is so much we don’t know about these famous Magi that is it important to nail down what we do. The historicity of the Wise Men points to the historicity of the light they sought—the Christ Child in the cradle of Bethlehem who is still venerated all these centuries later.  

The Wise Men also furnish us with an important lesson: despite all the risks, all the dangers in their path, they kept their eyes and minds fixed on the things above, not the things of earth. Their daring journey would not only gift them with immortality, but with a perpetual light that has continued to burn brighter than even their star.  

Read it here:   https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/why-so-much-wisdom-about-3-wise-men-christmas-story-actually-incorrect

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It is not covered in this article, but those Magi did not even come to see the family until after Jesus was around 2years old. We know this based upon the command from Herod to kill all male children from 2 years old to new born babes. When joseph and Mary then fled to Egypt it was well after Jesus was born. Yet, we still include them in the Manger scenes when they were not even there.

  • Love 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the point is; they came, honored Him, and recognized Him as King. Timing is irrelevant. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On the myrrh—the gold (given to a king) and the frankincense (given to a priest)—are somewhat self-explanatory. The myrrh, on the other hand, was not only used in temple rites. It was used as an analgesic, which Jesus refused to drink (Mk. 15:23; Matthew calls it “gall” due to the bitter taste, Matt. 27:34). The Lord was even buried (according to the Jewish custom) with myrrh (Jn. 19:39).

In the death of the Priest-King (who died for all people of all nations), that one little spice played a rather noticeable role. Those three gifts of the magi (whether they knew it or not) foreshadowed what was to come. It’s just a little something to meditate on.

Edited by Sundblom Santa
  • Love 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Days
  • Hours
  • Minutes
  • Seconds
  • Donations

    All donations go directly towards the cost of hosting and running ClausNet!

    Your support, through donations or simply by clicking on sponsor links, is greatly appreciated!

    Donate Sidebar by DevFuse
  • Our picks

    • Published by William B. Gilley in 1821, “The Children’s Friend. Number III. A New-Year’s Present to the Little Ones from Five to Twelve”, is believed to be the first book published in America to include lithographic illustrations. This book includes a poem about “Santeclaus” along with eight colored illustrations.

      However, what makes this book significant is the poem and illustrations are thought to be the earliest known visual representation of Santa Claus in a sleigh pulled by reindeer. The poem also marks Santa’s first appearance on Christmas Day rather than December 6, the feast day of St. Nicholas.


      The Children’s Friend. Number III.
      A New-Year’s Present to the Little Ones from Five to Twelve
      by William B. Gilley, 1821

      Old Santeclaus with much delight
       His reindeer drives this frosty night.
       O’er chimney tops, and tracks of snow,
       To bring his yearly gifts to you.

       The steady friend of virtuous youth,
       The friend of duty, and of truth,
       Each Christmas eve he joys to come
       Where love and peace have made their home”

       Through many houses he has been,
       And various beds and stockings seen,
       Some, white as snow, and neatly mended,
       Others, that seem’d for pigs intended.

       Where e’er I found good girls or boys,
       That hated quarrels, strife and noise,
       Left an apple, or a tart,
       Or wooden gun, or painted cart;

       To some I gave a pretty doll,
       To some a peg-top, or a ball;
       No crackers, cannons, squibs, or rockets,
       To blow their eyes up, or their pockets.

       No drums to stun their Mother’s ear,
      Nor swords to make their sisters fear;
      But pretty books to store their mind
       With knowledge of each various kind.

       But where I found the children naughty,
       In manners rude, in temper haughty,
       Thankless to parents, liars, swearers,
       Boxers, or cheats, or base tale-bearers,

       I left a long, black, birchen rod,
       Such as the dread command of God
       Directs a Parent’s hand to use
       When virtue’s path his sons refuse
        • Like
      • 3 replies
    • 10 Essentials to Being a Better Santa
      Here are some DOs and DON'Ts on being Santa

      Treat every child with respect.

      Never make fun of a child.

      Look into the child’s eyes when you speak to them.

      Speak softly. Children are sharing confidences with you.

      Acknowledge a child’s requests even if you don’t understand them.

      Never promise a toy request to avoid a child’s disappointment.

      Never promise a pet. Santas a toymaker and only animals produce pets.

      If the child can’t remember their wish list, assure them you know what they want.

      Never leave a child wondering if Santa heard their Christmas wishes.

      Every child worries about being on Santas “Naughty or Nice List”. Tell each child “You’re on the “Nice List.” It will bring happiness to everyone!   

      Santa Lou Knezevich is the creator of the Legendary Santas Mentoring Program
      Contact Santa Lou at: LegendarySantasMentoringProg@gmail.com
        • Thanks
        • Love
        • Like
      • 8 replies
    • How do You Portray Santa?
      Portraying Santa is acting; it is a characterization of a mythical character.

      Most of us never think of ourselves as actors, but we are. Certain characteristics of Santa Claus have been handed down from one generation to another. The way we dress and conduct ourselves all follow an established pattern.

      Santa Claus is one of the most recognizable characters throughout the world. This came about from the advertising campaign of the Coke Cola Company and the creative painting genius, of Haddon Sundblom. Coke Cola was looking to increase winter sales of its soft drink and hired Sundblom to produce illustrations for prominent magazines. These illustrations appeared during the holiday season from the late 1930s into the early 1970s and set the standard for how Santa should look.

      This characterization of Santa with rosy cheeks, a white beard, handlebar mustache plus a red costume trimmed in white fur is the image most everyone has in their minds. Unconsciously people are going to judge you against that image. If your beard isn’t white or you have a soiled suit it will register with the onlooker.

      By the way, the majority of Sundblom's paintings depict Santa with a Brown Belt and Brown Boots. Not until his later illustrations did he change the color to Black for these items. Within the past few years many costume companies have offered the Coke Cola Suit and it has become very popular. You can tell it by the large buttons and absence of fur down the front of the jacket.

      No matter how you portray Santa, be it home visits, schools, churches, parades, corporate events, malls, hospitals we all make an entrance and an impression! The initial impression we make determines if our client will ask us to return.

      The 5 Second Rule

      I have a theory: When you enter the presence of your audience you have about 5 seconds to make people believe you are the real Santa.
        • Thanks
        • Love
        • Like
      • 18 replies
    • Not Everyone Can Be Santa!
      Yes, I said it and it is not meant to hurt anyone’s feelings. I do view many Facebook sites along with websites and posted photos. Frankly, many of these postings should have never been put on public display.
        • Thanks
        • Love
        • Like
      • 10 replies
    • Auld Lang Syne
      Every New Year’s Eve at the stroke of midnight, millions around the world traditionally gather together to sing the same song, “Auld Lang Syne”. As revilers mumble though the song’s versus, it often brings many of them to tears – regardless of the fact that most don’t know or even understand the lyrics. Confusion over the song’s lyrics is almost as much of a tradition as the song itself. Of course that rarely stops anyone from joining in.
        • Wow
        • Thanks
        • Love
        • Like
      • 4 replies
  • Create New...